01
Can a recorder imitate a researcher?
Feynman moves from provenance labels to world challenges: could a complete record merely memorize templates rather than handle new parameters? V6.5 adds judgeable challenge responses, world-evidence accounting, prequential scoring and an explanation court to separate executable mechanisms, conservative delivery and HONEST_ZERO. The authoritative architecture is the r2 design.
02
Account for evidence by origin and use
A backend label alone cannot grant discovery eligibility. World-evidence events record type, observed value, credit cap and cost; synthetic, smoke, self-authored and diorama events have zero caps. Explanations face ballast, reach and regeneration checks. Frontier records ask what new evidence actually changes, rather than counting presentation complexity as progress.
03
Challenges, accounting and explanation court
The flow constructs candidates and challenge certificates, connects hard audit, world settlement and world-evidence accounting, then adds prequential metering, duel ordering, learning-progress scheduling and an explanation court. Default metadata-only candidates do not request claim-layer credit and receive HONEST_ZERO. An explicit Full-stack fixture adds sorted() code and a demonstration witness, reaching the older higher-tier classification.
04
Event credit and challenge protocol
WEEvent carries event type, observed bits, an MI cap, claim-layer status, cost and payload; credited bits are clipped by observed and type-level limits. Challenge configuration defines recorder capacity, query and answer spaces and rounds. These bounds depend on the stipulated toy world and recorder assumptions. The bit unit is an accounting convention, not measured general research information gain.
05
Conservative and demonstration packages
Inputs include topic, mode budget, challenge settings and the discovery-fixture switch. Outputs include challenges, per-candidate audit records, world settlement, evidence events, prediction traces, explanation checks and frontier metrics. A conservative package can legitimately record no discovery evidence. The fixture demonstrates module composition; its older PASS_DISCOVERY label does not establish a public scientific finding.
06
Conceptual walkthrough: fresh parameters
In the controlled challenge world, a recorder memorizes a bounded set of queries at one parameterization, while an executable responder computes results for fresh queries and parameters. Multiple rounds illustrate the difference. This tests behavior under the stipulated protocol, not real-world research superiority; the source responder can call the toy world's answer function and is not an external blinded experiment.
07
From stamps to challenge responses
Compared with Lakatos, Feynman focuses on fresh judgeable questions and credit flowing through world events. Noether's later audit identifies two key problems: this version's nominal V6.2 hard audit imitates only three gate shapes, and the fixture can reach PASS_DISCOVERY. The archive preserves the design while showing how later fixes change its evidence semantics.
08
A transition before true wiring
Source composes a challenge protocol, world-event ledger, prequential meter, explanation court and frontier metrics. hard_audit/v62_adapter.py actually creates three schema, compile and replay gate names without calling the real V6.2 labs and gates. The modules and dataflow exist, but the adapter does not establish complete EulerForge verification of a candidate.
09
Zero credit and older labels
HONEST_ZERO is a meaningful output: the default flow lacks content sufficient for discovery credit. sorted(), hand-authored witnesses and toy challenges can exercise interfaces, but do not establish new algorithms, information-theoretic contributions or autonomous research ability. The old PASS_DISCOVERY label is a historical software classification corrected by V6.6, not a finding to carry forward.
Reading example · Explaining the workflow
A controlled recorder–executor comparison
A toy challenge with a query index and fresh parameters.
- 01
Specify recorder capacity, answer space and rounds.
- 02
Issue parameterized challenges and record responses.
- 03
The world judge determines the protocol outcome.
- 04
Account by event type and caps; synthetic demonstrations do not earn scientific credit.
Challenge-response and accounting records.
Conceptual controlled-protocol walkthrough; not a real research blind review, and the older fixture label is later corrected.
Changes in this version
Eligibility
- Earlier approach
Provenance stamps and reinstantiation
- This version’s approach
Fresh world challenges and response certificates
Inspect parameterized behavior
Accounting
- Earlier approach
Elo changes on settlements
- This version’s approach
Type-specific world-evidence caps
Separate demonstration from claim content
Later correction
- Earlier approach
Three-gate imitation and fixture PASS_DISCOVERY
- This version’s approach
V6.6 true gates and PASS_DEMO
Restore correct demonstration semantics